Public Good - Te Iwi Whānui

  • Home
  • About us
    • About public good
    • Who is Behind Public Good?
    • Write for Public Good
    • Join us
      • Funding
  • Public Good Articles
  • Resources
    • Public Good Networks in NZ and around the world
  • Democracy
  • Events
    • Conference 2018
  • Sectors
    • Arts and Culture
    • Children
    • Education
      • Tertiary Education
    • Employment
    • Government
    • Health
    • Justice
    • Sustainable Business
    • The Economy
    • The Environment
  • Sex and Gender
You are here: Home / Govt action on climate change? No we’re perfect already

15 December 2015 by Jan Rivers

Govt action on climate change? No we’re perfect already

The government says it is leading an international initiative of countries who are looking at how to cut carbon use by cutting fossil fuel subsidies. Friends of Fossil Fuel Subsidy Reform includes a number of governments, commercial companies, including many from New Zealand, as well as some international environmental organisations*.

The idea that there is no point in putting a ‘price on carbon’ through a tax or trading regime while there are subsidies in place is a reasonable one.  There is  solid research by the IMF in this area demonstrating the negative impact  of fossil fuel subsidies and the potential gains from their removal. That seems fair enough then. The proposal from the Friends is that the money released by cutting subsidies could be reinvested in renewable energy projects.  That makes sense as well.

However there is a big credibility problem for New Zealand’s government. An article on the Friends website speaks of 3 areas for  fossil fuel subsidy reform. These are  subsidies to producers  (oil and coal companies), generators (the electricity companies) and consumers  (private individuals and businesses). This is where it gets tricky for New Zealand. According to the Prime Minister the NZ government is proposing to target only 1 strand of subsidies – those to consumers. Subsidies to fossil fuel exploration and drilling in NZ the Prime Minister says, are “not subsidisation in terms of what the world is talking about” .  So the NZ government’s approach is an interesting one. In MBIE’s own research on subsidies for fossil fuels seven subsidies of eight identified are producer subsidies. Since subsidies to LPG and CNG as vehicle fuel were withdrawn the sole consumer fossil fuel subsidy is a tax rebate to farmers and vessel owners on the basis that their use of fuel does not take place on roads. On the other hand the examples of producer subsidies include allowing Solid Energy not to pay the costs of remediating mining sites and providing  government funded support (such as providing geological survey information to prospectors) and tax incentives for oil exploration.

So the $500bn per annum that the Friends website identifies as global fossil fuel subsidies are actually only the subsidies to consumers (and which is supported in other research) are made mainly to address fuel poverty and  are barely relevant in New Zealand **.  IMF research says they also make up only 6% of the $5.3 trillion a year of subsidies to fossil fuels internationally.  (Overall these subsidies are equivalent to 6.5% of global GDP and are several orders of magnitude more than subsidies to renewables which are running at $120bn/year).

It would be very easy to stop subsidizing oil exploration, drilling and fracking. A pricing regime to differentiate between renewable and fossil fuel power generation is trickier but still possible***. These subsidies are made to a small number of readily identifiable extraction and power generation companies  and would be easy to cut.

The focus on consumer subsidies in preference to the much larger, real, identifiable and measurable subsidies made to fossil fuel companies gives the impression that the government is determined to pull it’s policy paddles through the air, rather than dipping them in the water where they might actually make a difference.

Other References

*There is limited information about why the companies have signed up – just a set of company logos and many of the other ‘friends’ countries make no statement about what their commitment to cutting subsidies consists of.

** The argument being made is that NZ stopped subsidising consumer fossil fuel use when support to installing LPG and CNG happened decades ago. If there are minimal consumer fossil fuel subsidies in NZ then it follows that they cannot be targetted as an effective means of cutting emissions.

In other overseas jurisdictions switching consumer fuel subsidies (often for cooking and heating fuel) from fossil fuels to renewable energy would be beneficial to the environment and several poorer countries have already achieved this even though consumer side subsidies are dwarfed  by extractor subsidies.

*** The MBIE research doesn’t include the uniform pricing of electricity, which is also effectively a subsidy to fossil fuel generation.  Unit for unit renewable energy is always cheaper (and less polluting) than fossil fuel electricity generation.  The absence of any analysis of this easily spotted issue begs the question of how thorough the thinking has been about identifying subsidies to NZ fossil fuel use.

 

 

Filed Under: Uncategorised Tagged With: Democracy

hands around the world

Latest on Twitter

Public Good – Te Iwi Whānui Invitation: Family violence - working through a complex problem. - eepurl.com/g-pGBX

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

Public Good – Te Iwi Whānui Invitation: Family violence - working through a complex problem. - eepurl.com/g7kMpn

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

Public Good – Te Iwi Whānui Invitation: Family violence - working through a complex problem. - eepurl.com/gWiCsD

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

Public Good – Te Iwi Whānui Invitation: Family violence - working through a complex problem. - eepurl.com/gDsUIb

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

Invitation: Next Friday 26 July Family Violence: Working our way through a complex problem. at St ANdrew's on the Terrace Professor Dawn Elder & Dr Ben Gray from Otago Medical School Wgtn publicgood.org.nz/20…

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

Public Good – Te Iwi Whānui Invitation: Family violence - working through a complex problem. - eepurl.com/gxvfAz

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

Glad I've been reading @caitoz who from Australia & with no insider knowledge has been outlining the farce of Russiagate, She and others have some well earned praise. caitlinjohnstone.com…

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

A few last minute spaces if this sounds like you. Mindful people build the future. Starts Sunday 5.30 - 7.00 at St Andrew's on the Terrace in Wellington. Could there be societal impacts of widely adopted meditation? Could those impacts include you? scoop.co.nz/stories/…

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

Public Good – Te Iwi Whānui Invitation to Education and Political Literacy in New Zealand - eepurl.com/gkvnkj

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

@AnneliseJoy @radionz a) its a news website - publicly funded addressing an issue about a bill that has been withdrawn b) to the right of the article there are more stories written from an uncritical pro trans view c) You are claiming fear,ignorance & hate? I don't see that. What are you seeing?

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

Follow @PublicGoodANZ

Recent Facebook Posts

No recent Facebook posts to show

Latest on Facebook

Newsletter Sign-Up

What Public Good is about

  • There is peace in dungeons, but is that enough to make dungeons desirable? Jean-Jacques Rousseau
    The Social Contract
  • Healthy democracy requires the voice of dissent. Rosemary Neave

Dig Deeper

Contacts

Authorised by Jan Rivers
Wellington 6012
New Zealand
Email
Text/Ph: 022 126 1839


Public Good Website by Rosemary Neave
Web2blog.co.nz

Join our Monthly Email List

givealittleGive a Little to support Public Good

Latest Comments

  • Jan Rivers on Media Council finds Stuff endorses unbalanced coverage on puberty blockers
  • Rodney Hide on Media Council finds Stuff endorses unbalanced coverage on puberty blockers

Copyright © 2023 · Executive Pro Theme on Genesis Framework