Public Good

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • About us
    • About public good
    • Who is Behind Public Good?
    • Write for Public Good
  • Join us
    • Funding
  • Public Good Articles
  • PG Top Books
  • Links
  • Democracy
  • Events
    • Conference 2014
  • Sectors
    • Arts and Culture
    • Children
    • Education
      • Tertiary Education
    • Employment
    • Government
    • Health
    • Justice
    • Sustainable Business
    • The Economy
    • The Environment
You are here: Home / Democracy / A story of being a claimant in the “good times”.

September 22, 2017 by Jan Rivers

A story of being a claimant in the “good times”.

 

The sight of Metiria Turei going alone to meet staff at the WINZ office about her 20 year old over-payment during the election campaign was an experience that raised the hairs on the back of my neck. Visiting the benefit office for an interview is amongst the most challenging memories of my young life. It was a long time ago when I lived in the UK and came about because within weeks of leaving university I broke my leg. It took a year to mend, another three months before I was fully mobile again and two years in all before I found a job.

After about a year I was called in to the Social Security department for a review meeting and put into a windowless room. The door was locked behind me and I was grilled about why I had no job, even though the evidence of my broken leg must have been in my notes and I was still limping. I was put on a three monthly review with what felt like threats to cut my unemployment benefits. This was infuriating but also terrifying. There were few jobs locally even though Swansea was a good-sized town.

I found the experience of unemployment & needing to claim benefits was a series of almost permanent Catch 22 situations that would not have been out of place in I, Daniel Blake. As in that film, there was some individual kindness, but it failed to counter the systemic cruelty of the experience.

I recall that there was a lot of street knowledge about how to present yourself to the Social Security office. Meetings always felt risky, as if presenting your facts in the wrong order meant that a different interpretation could see the benefit cut. There were worries that being an irritant to the staff would bring about a change or delay to your benefit eligibility which made the interactions very tense.

Like Metiria, I lived in a situation where friends moved in & out and this impacted the benefit available and had to be reported, which involved hours waiting on the phone to the benefit office or spent in waiting rooms clutching a numbered ticket alongside people who were sometimes angry and emotional. Together with the worries of having little money for emergencies or being unable to pay bills and the rent, I continued to apply for jobs and attend interviews and not only from fear. I wanted desperately to make a start to my adult life and each doctor visit estimated that “another six weeks” would see my leg mended.

The stresses were nothing compared to what beneficiaries have faced since the 1991 “Mother of All Budgets” though. Our tenancy remained assured provided we paid the rent, which was controlled by legislation, and the house was subject to minimum standards which were an effective “warrant of fitness”. It didn’t get to needing to go to food-banks — if they were available at the time I don’t remember and mostly I could pay the bills. Even so I found these apparently generous times unremittingly harsh. There was a gradual but ongoing diminishment in the quality of my circumstances. The deterioration of personal belongings — shoes and clothes, household equipment and furniture were patched, cracked, faded and broken or partially working. I became depressed and angry at the world. I recall being tense-jawed, dry-eyed and unable to cry. Sometimes the effect of what I did in this frame of mind made my situation worse. I started to have panic attacks and vertigo, and spent time thinking I was going mad.  Being dependent, even on a supposedly properly provisioned social security system was for me an extremely harsh experience.  I can hardly imagine what current beneficiaries are faced with in contrast.

Telling this story makes me aware of the way that Metiria’s story was endlessly picked over, speculated on, unpacked for casual analysis and judgement. Why didn’t she just do this? What about family, relatives, ex-partner, in-laws, addresses, options? The hoary maxim that “explaining is losing” in our politics is sadly true and Metiria did explain and did not resort to ‘cease and desist’ injunctions, defamation charges, throwing money at the problem or buying silence or any of the other things that the powerful in our society commonly do to make problems vanish. In this she was identifiably like all of us who wield little public power. She reminds us that there is no perfect person, certainly no perfect claimant when everything we do — accepting gifts, being taken out to dinner, accepting baby-sitting or care for children from flatmates, friends, relatives and in-laws — can, in public life, be subject to scrutiny. So being able to maintain and benefit from supportive relationships is construed as dishonesty and this has its corollary in the current benefits system. The WINZ website says that beneficiaries who receive gifts while receiving an accommodation allowance must declare them for assessment as income.

We all live with complexity, vulnerability and imperfection — with hopes and fears about people who can care for us but who we do not want to be beholden to or who cannot fund our costs and house us. And in any case benefits should be rights — part of the Social Contract — not subject to judgments about whether we are deemed deserving.

My eventual escape was a move to London to find a job and join my partner. We were part of  a squatting community next to a small urban park. We had a loo but no bathroom so used the local public baths with wonderful Victorian tubs, tiles and copper plumbing. I had no resources initially and so paying rent at the outset would have been impossible but compared to claiming social security being a squatter with a job was a breeze.

The impact of these two years trashed my self-esteem and confidence and it took years to rebuild. My experience has meant I do not judge anyone who is on a benefit. Payment levels that are set below the levels needed to survive necessarily bring behaviour that can be described as criminal in its wake.  In addition benefit fraud is most certainly treated differently from tax fraud as University of Victoria Associate Professor Lisa Marriott’s research has shown even though it is generally about survival not about relative wealth. The potential to be investigated never expires for beneficiaries and even securing a loan and not declaring it is being treated by the courts as fraudulent . Surviving on a benefit may require people to take risks with legality that more fortunate people would never consider. If the alternative is a collapse into depression and worse the price seems very high.

Recently I did a submission to the suicide strategy and in the preparatory reading discovered that the number of suicides more than doubled in the years after 1984 and for women rose again following the 1991 benefit cuts. What this demonstrates to me is that some of the people who struggled with Metiria did not make it.

Filed Under: Democracy Tagged With: beneficiary, benefit, DPB, Metiria, social security, welfare

Logging In...

Comments are closed.

  • 1 Reply
  • 1 Comment
  • 0 Tweets
  • 0 Facebook
  • 0 Pingbacks
Last reply was 6 months ago
  1. Marie
    View 6 months ago

    Thank you for this interesting story and information about WINZ.

hands around the world

Latest on Twitter

@alans_world Yes my early years were spent noticing disabled ex soldiers 1&2 WW survivors (& later Korea, Cyprus) including relatives who were withdrawn, angry and/or disabled altho' grandad who was in the cavalry in Egypt had plenty of stories.

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

@alans_world This is what JB Priestley said in 1933 when his regiment met for dinner and several men were to ashamed to come attend as they could not bear to be seen in the clothes they would have had to wear. #Homefitforheroes #anzacday pic.twitter.com/FkNr…

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

@pjsmellie @pv_reynolds @NewsroomNZ Wind is expensive but isn't solar failing to get a foothold because the generation model is predicated on large generating plant & the wrong incentives are in place for solar to succeed.

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

@kahuranginp @transparency_a1 So about $1000 profit per NZ resident per year heads to Australian banks. This is about 14% of the total income tax take of NZ govt for no benefit.

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

@imaginemyrelief @farmgeek Yes indeed. There is an interesting article here about this & in the comments one on Germany's valiant experience of renewables newsroom.co.nz/2018/….

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

@pjsmellie @pv_reynolds @NewsroomNZ Internationally subsidies to extraction are huge (10 *) compared with those to fossil fuel consumption. theguardian.com/envi…

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

@pjsmellie @pv_reynolds @NewsroomNZ Selling fossil fuel generated electricity at the same price as renewable is an effective subsidy to the former. Per Kilowatt renewable is much cheaper to generate.

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

@MacFinlay @onya_nz Most of us wouldn't get to bore our best buddies with drivel like this let alone hog space in the national media & presuppose get paid to boot. nzherald.co.nz/index…

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

@tommundaycs Partly true but "my editor would stop me if I wrote about austerity" said 12 NZ journos to me as core gov't spending in NZ fell from 33 to 28% of GDP.

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

@MsWonderOutLoud @easegill . @OwenJones84 in the UK has written about deligitimising the Labour opposition. Are we are seeing the same here of the govt? Orchestrated, dishonest & malign. medium.com/@OwenJone…

From PublicGood-ANZ's Twitter

Follow @PublicGoodANZ

Recent Facebook Posts

No recent Facebook posts to show

Latest on Facebook

Give a little

What Public Good is about

  • There is peace in dungeons, but is that enough to make dungeons desirable? Jean-Jacques Rousseau
    The Social Contract
  • For us public service encompasses all the people who contribute to community well-being. public good

Most Recent Posts

  • Paradise Lost – Paradise regained
  • Can’t get no satisfaction from the NZ Herald
  • Participate in a submission to the Tax Working Group
  • Press complaint about NZ Herald article “How Labour just lost the 2020 election”
  • Book Review: National Enterprise – The development of the public corporation Ernest Davies Gollancz 1946

Dig Deeper

Contacts

Authorised by Jan Rivers
Wellington 6012
New Zealand
Email
Text/Ph: 022 126 1839


Public Good Website by Rosemary Neave
Web2blog.co.nz

Join our Monthly Email List

givealittleGive a Little to support Public Good

Posts

September 2017
M T W T F S S
« Aug   Oct »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
252627282930  

Latest Comments

  • Perce Harpham on Press complaint about NZ Herald article “How Labour just lost the 2020 election”
  • Ruby Woodward on Press complaint about NZ Herald article “How Labour just lost the 2020 election”

Copyright © 2018 · Executive Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in